Don't marry someone with whom you could not share this website.

The Grist and the Mill

The Grist and the MillThe Grist and the MillThe Grist and the Mill

The Grist and the Mill

The Grist and the MillThe Grist and the MillThe Grist and the Mill
  • Home
  • Publications
  • Censeo et Fragmenta
  • Variae
  • Ars Longa, Vita Brevis
  • Fabulae
  • Festivitas
  • About
  • More
    • Home
    • Publications
    • Censeo et Fragmenta
    • Variae
    • Ars Longa, Vita Brevis
    • Fabulae
    • Festivitas
    • About
  • Home
  • Publications
  • Censeo et Fragmenta
  • Variae
  • Ars Longa, Vita Brevis
  • Fabulae
  • Festivitas
  • About

Detours in the Fine Arts

Good Art? Bad Art?

Conversations about art tend to founder as soon as the  dread phrase "Well art is, after all, subjective" is uttered. In this clip, the late philosopher Roger Scruton disputes that idea. The distinction he makes is between a work of art that is popular, and one that displays technical excellence or points to some transcendent reality.

A few words from St. Thomas

  • "...beauty includes three conditions, 'integrity' or 'perfection,' since those things which are impaired are by the very fact ugly; due 'proportion' or 'harmony'; and lastly, 'brightness' or 'clarity'..."


  • "Because bodily delights are more generally known, 'the name of pleasure has been appropriated to them' (Ethic. vii, 13), although other delights excel them, and yet happiness does not consist in them. Because in everything, that which pertains to its essence is distinct from its proper accident: thus in man it is one thing that he is a mortal rational animal, and another that he is a risible animal. We must therefore consider that every delight is a proper accident resulting from happiness, or from some part of happiness; since the reason that a man is delighted is that he has some fitting good, either in reality, or in hope, or at least in memory. Now a fitting good, if indeed it be the perfect good, is precisely man's happiness: and if it is imperfect, it is a share of happiness, either proximate, or remote, or at least apparent…It comes to the same whether we desire good, or desire delight, which is nothing else than the appetite's rest in good…"


  • " 'Fruitio' [enjoyment] and 'fructus' [fruit] seem to refer to the same, one being derived from the other…the notion of fruit implies two things: first that it should come last; second, that it should calm the appetite with a certain sweetness and delight. Now a thing is last either simply or relatively; simply, if it be referred to nothing else; relatively, if it is the last in a particular series. Therefore that which is last simply, and in which one delights as in the last end, is properly called fruit; and this it is that one is properly said to enjoy. But that which is delightful not in itself, but is desired, only as referred to something else, e.g. a bitter potion for the sake of health, can nowise be called fruit. And that which has something delightful about it, to which a number of preceding things are referred, may indeed be called fruit in a certain manner; but we cannot be said to enjoy it properly or as though it answered perfectly to the notion of fruit."

Um, no thanks.

Bela Zombory-Moldovan

The Burning of the World

The author, a Hungarian painter, wrote a brief memoir of the opening months of the First World War. ZM was in the army and saw action along the Russian border. His account is filled with the same horror and chaos that one expects from a war journal, but what I enjoyed most was discovering ZM the artist and his circle of friends and contemporaries. (Below are some of my favourites.) Of particular interest are “The Eight” a group of avant garde painters who had staged a controversial exhibit in 1911. 

To my great profit, I paired ZM’s book with Austrian writer Stefan Zweig’s The World of Yesterday. Both raise many of the same issues: the catastrophic end of the world fittingly called “The Long 19th Century”, capitalism vs. socialism, the place of Jews in society, shifting morals, etc. One of the most entertaining chapters in ZM’s book was a visit to his uncle, a parson. Apart from this, both authors are tellingly silent about the topic of religion. 

   Despite their progressive leanings, however, both also exhibit a strong affection for the Austo-Hungarian Empire and a contempt for revolutionary and pro-war sentiment. Neither harboured the fashionable desire to see the world remade.  

ZM

"Lakeshore Promenade in Autumn"

Learn More

ZM

"Still Life in the Larder"

Zsigmond Vajda

Zsigmond Vajda

"Winter Cityscape"

Robert Bereny

Zsigmond Vajda

"Still Life  with Cat"

Lost Painting Recovered on Movie Set

Odon Tull

"The Harvesters"

Dezso Czigany

"Burial of a Child"

Bela Czobel

Bela Czobel

Bela Czobel

"Street in Paris"

Dezso Orban

Bela Czobel

Bela Czobel

"Garden of a Church"

Henryk Gorecki (1933-2010)

Symphony #3

My children are old enough now that we made them sit through a performance of Gorecki’s “Symphony of Sorrowful Songs.” I am especially fond of the final movement, with its repeating church-bell motif. Strong, bright melodies dominate the tragic lyrics: allusions to the Passion of Christ and the Compassion of Mary reassure us that our suffering will be transformed. Nazis, Bolsheviks, etc.,--they will all be swept away. Incidentally, I have never found anything in Gorecki's catalog that has remotely equaled this piece.

More about the Symphony #3

When Gorecki stunned the world.

They tried to cancel him.

Sahara, Columbia Pictures, 1943

Starring Humphrey Bogart

Rewatching Sahara, the 1943 movie starring Humphrey Bogart, I was not only impressed by the usual things--the direction, the acting, etc.--but I also enjoyed learning about the M3 tank. This sturdy, manoeuvrable beast was in active service with the U.S. Army through the 1950s but, during the war itself, was sidelined when the M4 Sherman debuted. The M3 came in two models, the Lee (used in the film) and the Grant, a sign that by 1943 Americans were sufficiently removed from the events of the 1860s that they could calmly weigh the merits of individuals who fought on both sides of the War Between the States. 

...and a "General Lee" M3

By the way the movie is as good, if not better, than I remembered. The story takes place in the aftermath of the battle of Tobruk and centers on a group of U.S. soldiers, and their sole remaining tank, fleeing across North Africa with the German army in pursuit. Along the way, they pick up several British and one French refugee, as well as a Sundanese officer and two prisoners, a German and an Italian. Plenty of action and intelligent drama.

The Cluny Movement

A reconstruction of the Benedictine Abbey of Cluny, in Burgundy

A reconstruction of the Benedictine Abbey of Cluny, in Burgundy

Dessin de l'abbaye de Cluny au XIIe siècle d'après une hypothèse de restitution de K.J Conant

Excerpts from Cluny: In Search of God's Lost Empire by Edwin Mullins:

Tournus

A reconstruction of the Benedictine Abbey of Cluny, in Burgundy

"In the year 987 [Mayeul] used his prestige as abbot, and no doubt his aristocratic connections, to persuade one of the most remarkable men of his day to come to Cluny…it was he [Guglielmo of Volpiano, a young noble, monk and reformer] more than anyone who was responsible for establishing the first truly international style of church architecture in Europe. He was the father of the Romanesque…

Uchizy

"...rounded arches and windows, simple classical columns with carved capitals, and usually a rounded apse beyond the altar at the eastern end. It became the predominant form of church architecture for over two hundred years until the evolution of the Gothic style late in the late twelfth century."  (p.28)


Vezelay

Bois-Sainte-Marie

"At its finest there is a warm humanist spirit about Clunaic stone carving..."  (p. 122)

Bois-Sainte-Marie

Bois-Sainte-Marie

Bois-Sainte-Marie

The Circuit des Eglises Romans in the Brionnais (pp. 123-124). 

Autun

Bois-Sainte-Marie

Bois-Sainte-Marie

"A lintel is long and narrow; hence both Adam and Eve needed to be horizontal and facing each other...Her right hand is cupped beneath her chin as she whispers secretly to Adam while her other hand reaches behind her to pluck the forbidden fruit." (pp. 218-219)

Mr. Bean can't be left alone with great art

"The Martyrdom and Apotheosis of St. Pantalon" by Giovanni Fumiani (1645-1710): the world's largest painting on canvas

Years ago I acquired eight books by Osbert Sitwell, and have enjoyed diving into them at random. Sitwell’s portraits of famous people and loving descriptions of important monuments and works of art, make for an easy, refreshing read. My favourite, Tales My Father Taught Me, is a series of humourous anecdotes about his father. Winters of Content (1932), meanwhile, has this striking passage:


"I know no painting in any church which can compare with it for daring, and even effrontery; none which exhibits so low a range of and such sinister depths of tone. It has none of the delicious colour or watery rhetoric, none of the river-gods and urns, pearls, and brocades, of Tiepolo, nothing grotesque, no strutting and feathered manikins striving to hold back their greyhounds, but...

"...in place of these, exhibits a terrifying and steely magnificence. We are transported into a grandiose, dark world of armoured giants and statues that are half shadow and half ogre; a world where anything may happen, where the figure of the Comendador may creak to awful life, or the echoes of our voices, caught by the wind, may come back to us distorted… “

Hayao Miyazaki (1941- )

Founder, Studio Ghibli

The king of Japanese animated film (anime), has enjoyed worldwide success over a fifty-year career. Many Americans, however, seem to be only casually familiar with his work. Perhaps it is because anime is mistakenly assumed to be only for consumption by children and teens. On the contrary, I would venture to say that the majority of anime films and TV series, for better or worse, are aimed at teens and adults. While some can be quite violent and brooding, Miyazaki’s films are decidedly mature without losing their broad appeal. Humour and escapism typically rub elbows with the great questions of life. I find his mythic stories to be worthy of repeated viewings and consider My Neighbor Totoro to be a nearly perfect film. 


   In terms of artistic technique, Miyazaki is famous for his adherence to traditional, hand-drawn animation and his insistence upon natural realism. His characters move fluidly and his landscapes are vibrant. Turning to his artistic temperament, Miyazaki typically fills the roles of animator, writer, producer, and director. This can be quite exhausting and he has “retired” many times only to return. In fact, two of his best films were made when he was in his 60s--hope for us all!

A List of My Favourites

Miyazaki/Studio Ghibli

1. My Neighbor Totoro

2. Spirited Away

3. Howl’s Moving Castle

4. Castle in the Clouds

5. Nausicaa and the Valley of the Wind

6. Arrietty

7. When Marnie Was There

8. Whisper of the Heart and its quasi-sequel The Cat Returns


Other artists/studios

1. Okko’s Inn

2. The House of the Lost on the Cape

2. Suzume

3. A Whisker Away

Learn More

Giovanni Bellini (1430-1516)

St. Jerome Reading

St. Francis of Assisi in the Desert

“Almost alone among supremely great artists Bellini is optimistic. He had known tragedy in his youth, but in middle age he came to look for those things in life that are calm and life-giving. Men, landscapes, buildings, all take on this feeling of natural goodness.”   Kenneth Clark, The Other Half

Copyright © 2026 The Grist and the Mill - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept